The Grotto Pizzeria

  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon

New York, United States

thegrottony.com
Pizza restaurant

The Grotto Pizzeria Reviews | Rating 4,4 out of 5 stars

The Grotto Pizzeria is located in New York, United States on 69 New St. The Grotto Pizzeria is rated 4.4 out of 5 in the category pizza restaurant in United States.

Address

69 New St

Price range

$$$

Phone

+1 2128096990

Service options

No-contact deliveryDeliveryTakeawayDine-in

Amenities

Gender-neutral toiletsGood for kidsToilets

Accessibility

Offerings

Comfort foodQuick biteSmall plates

Best known for
Fresh Sushi
Biggest weakness
Inconsistent service
Most praised
Value for Money
Recommended for
Families, Sushi lovers
Write review Claim Profile

S
Saggio Ricercatore

Friendly folks serving an authentic NY slice - big & foldable with excellent red sauce & variety of fresh toppings to choose from. Delicious gluten free crust option also. Excellent green salad with strawberries, goat cheese & balsamic dressing. Homey, hole in the wall.

D
David Zandi

Many years ago when I worked on Wall Street, our company had account with Grotto... and we got free lunch. I recall it was some of the best Italian food I had in my life. Now, many years later... after dreaming about their food. I ended up back in NYC for a week and made sure my hotel was booked next to it, so I could eat here as often as I can. My favorite, is their fried ravioli with honey mustard, their penne ala vodka, their baked ziti and you must try their curly fries, which is the best fries you will have in this lifetime ️

A
Atlas Mcfarland

I dine in this great restaurant from time to time! This is my favorite place to eat. I visit this spot routinely. The meals are excellent, the staff is courteous and the payment is good. I like going in this spot to have a rich lunch.

C
C D

The customer service on the phone isn't as warm and friendly to my liking nor was I fond of the Jamaican beef patty. The beef patty was burned and the edges were hard to chew. But, the grilled chicken rigatoni and sausage penne was outstanding !! Very filling and delicious!! I will try them again when I'm in the area.

V
Vickie Phoenix

OMG it was amazing don't think I can eat one anywhere else now... I am just waiting for some time on my schedule so can go down and sit and try whatever they have to offer lol.

Open hours