Stottlemyer's Smokehouse

  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon

Sarasota, United States

stottlemyerssmokehouse.com
American restaurant· Bar & grill· Live music venue· Southern restaurant (US)· American· Barbecue· Barbecue restaurant· Bar· Floridian restaurant· Pizza restaurant

Stottlemyer's Smokehouse Reviews | Rating 4,2 out of 5 stars

Stottlemyer's Smokehouse is located in Sarasota, United States on 19 E Rd. Stottlemyer's Smokehouse is rated 4.2 out of 5 in the category american restaurant in United States.

Address

19 E Rd

Price range

$$

Phone

+1 9413125969

Best known for
Fresh Sushi
Biggest weakness
Inconsistent service
Most praised
Value for Money
Recommended for
Families, Sushi lovers
Write review Claim Profile

J
Jennifer Eastburn, Realtor
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ☆

A local fave. This place came highly recommended to us to try. The food was yummy! My husband said the cornbread was best he's ever had and BBQ was delicious! Loved the atmosphere and music. However, we must have went on an off night. They were packed as expected, but the server couldn't hear us because of music, I guess, and we got a lot of incorrect food, my daughters hamburger was raw and other tables were complaining too. Manager did come up to us and apologize and said they were short staffed. We will definitely go back and try again! I was s server for a lot of years when I was younger so I get it! You can't always have a perfect night and please everyone! Food was good enough to give it another shot!

S
Sarah Robertson
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★

My first experience there and it was great! Great food, I tried the BBQ nachos and they were great! Great variety of food from BBQ, Italian, chinese, Mexican and pizza! Live bands every day of the week which is a fun vibe. Ask for Cheryl! She was so kind and warm and funny and makes you feel like family!! We will definitely be back! Oh and try the corn bread! You won't be disappointed!

M
Maria S Nasca
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ☆

Fun place, outside seating, live entertainment and great BBQ. I got the combo, bbribs, pulled chicken, brisket and collard greens and baked beans. All was excellent except for the ribs. They were good, but not fall off the bone good. A bit tough. The corn bread is EXCELLENT. The best corn bread ever... no butter needed. Served hot! ... its a great place to meet friends or family as its all pretty much outdoors.

T
Tyler Hoffman
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ☆
  • ☆

The food was delicious and it came out hot right away, but the overall experience was hard to separate from the hygiene of the staff, especially during COVID, was frankly, pretty gross. I am not here to tear anyone down. I had no intention of even publicly addressing it, but their website has no contact us page. I do not use Facebook. If I could have an email to contact with my specific issues, please get in touch with me.

M
Matthew
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ☆

The last few times I've been here the food has been great! The BBQ has been spot on every time! The Cuban sandwich was delicious, albeit a bit frugal with the portions, but overall it was very very tasty! The Brisket taco's (a daily special) were also fantastic! I've heard a lot of people rave about their pizza too. Bit of a warning though.. depending on the band playing music, your dining experience could turn into a wild fun night. ;)

Open hours