Grey Lady Montauk

  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon

Montauk, United States

greyladymtk.com
Restaurant· New England restaurant

Grey Lady Montauk Reviews | Rating 3.4 out of 5 stars (8 reviews)

Grey Lady Montauk is located in Montauk, United States on 440 W Lake Dr. Grey Lady Montauk is rated 3.4 out of 5 in the category restaurant in United States.

Address

440 W Lake Dr

Price range

$

Phone

+1 6316688681

Service options

Outdoor seatingTakeawayDine-in

Amenities

Bar on siteToilets

Accessibility

Wheelchair-accessible car parkWheelchair-accessible entranceWheelchair-accessible seatingWheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings

AlcoholBeerCocktailsCoffeeSmall platesSpiritsWine

Open hours

...
Write review Claim Profile

M

Michael Bogino

We were here in September 2020. Not too busy, but outrageously overpriced for what you get: mediocre food, slow service, and subpar drinks. I can’t imagine how bad it would have been if they were actually full since they could barely handle 50% capacity. There are so many other great options in Montauk.

C

Christopher Sandoval

Absolute ripoff. Not worth it. For a place that requires table minimums service is absolutely awful, prices are steep, and the bouncers are extremely rude. There are other establishments nearby (surf lodge, ruschmyers, montauket, Dureyeas, Navy Beach) that will be more enjoyable and worth your time.

S

Simon Gill

RUDE STAFF! My girlfriend recently made reservations for her friend's bachelorette at 10pm but when they arrive one of the staff members told them that their reservation was for tomorrow and not today. The girls showed him on their calendar that it was for tonight but he refused to let them in and said, "No you’re not coming in and good luck trying to find a place at this time. You’re better off going to a drive thru." He was rude and had them stand in the cold weather for couple of minutes. Looks like they don't want people coming in since other customers have similar complaints with them (read other reviews) so highly suggest PLEASE do yourself a favor and don't make reservations here!!!! Thank you!

A

Alex Masotta

They only accept reservations online for parties of 4, but called to make a reservation for two. Was told to make it online for 4 and add a note. Then they cancelled our reservation last minute because they saw the note. Now, unable to book anywhere else for a Saturday night. Amazing people... -___-

A

Art Fursenko

Very fresh seafood, great late season, whole town to yourself

А

Антонио Дамянов

I think they got the wrong manager or something... I’m sure they can do better!

J

Joseph Westervelt

The bald headed bartender hit on my wife while I was in the bathroom... manager & waitstaff were rude to my friends as well. Spend your money somewhere else. This place will hopefully be out of business soon . . .

R

RanTan Pushkin

Didn't eat inside took food out and it was good