Search Icon

Made in New York Pizza

  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon

New York, United States

madeinnymenu.com
restaurant· Pizza· Pizza restaurant

Made in New York Pizza Reviews | Rating 4,7 out of 5 stars

Made in New York Pizza is located in New York, United States on 421 Amsterdam Ave. Made in New York Pizza is rated 4.7 out of 5 in the category restaurant in United States.

Address

421 Amsterdam Ave

Price range

$$$

Phone

+1 6464846200

Service options

Outdoor seatingNo-contact deliveryDeliveryTakeawayDine-in

Amenities

Good for kidsToilets

Accessibility

No wheelchair-accessible car park

Offerings

Comfort foodLate-night foodQuick biteVegetarian options

Best known for
Fresh Sushi
Biggest weakness
Inconsistent service
Most praised
Value for Money
Recommended for
Families, Sushi lovers
Write review Claim Profile
F
Fiona Dominick
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ☆

I love the pizza, salad, chicken wings and the cheesecake. This place is excellent. The service is very good. The floor is clean and the tallies and seats are clean

C
C Rod
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ☆

Excellent spicy pepperoni square. but I really like the sausage slice. It's not a 5 star only cause my favorite new york pizza has a coal oven on Spring st.

D
Diana Saucer
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★

What a wonderful restaurant! The pizza and pasta were delicious. Besides, the crust, sauces, and methods of cooking were impressive and satisfying. Honestly, my husband and I greatly loved this restaurant, so we visit here from time to time. Also, the place was clean, perfect for a date, and stylish. Others must come!

J
Jeff Gebott
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★

Great UWS slice spot. Sam is the man. Get the jalapeño and sausage, the spicy pepperoni, and the vodka slices. Pretty solid beer list too.

D
Dwight Kenneth
  • ★
  • ★
  • ★
  • ☆
  • ☆

Spicy pepperoni is the go to slice! For 4.50 it’s not bad especially for the quality of the ingredients and the location. Convenient location for a late night snack. The small pepperonis are always the best as they curl up and have the little oil cups that everyone prefers. The dough is okay, nothing too fancy. The service was efficient as there was no line on the day we went. The sauce was just over salted on the day we went. Hopefully it won’t be as salty next time we come in.

Open hours

Close